The Elephant Man LOD

Never. Oh, never. Nothing will die. The stream flows, the wind blows, the cloud fleets, the heart beats. Nothing will die. - Alfred Lord Tennyson

Study of the domain

Image

Study of the domain

Idea

"And then the Industrial Revolution. You know images of explosions, big explosions? They always reminded me of the papillomas, the growths on John Merrick's body: they looked like slow explosions that started from the bones."


David Lynch, Lynch on Lynch

Joseph Carey Merrick was an English man known for his severe physical deformities lived during the Victorian Era, at the end of the XIX century. Thanks to photographic representations of the time his physical appearance and the diagnosis of his condition, Proteus Syndrome, became known. From childhood, he suffered from a rare disease that made his skin spongy and saggy. His upper lip protruded outwards, vaguely resembling a proboscis, which earned him his nickname, "The Elephant Man". The tumours and excrescences that cover Merrick's body make him a being destined for confinement in freak shows, the only place where he could be exhibited while limiting the offensive potential inherent in his physical constitution. When he was not performing, however, he covered his head with a large hat.

As recounted by his protector, Dr. Frederick Treves, in his book The Elephant Man and Other Reminiscences, he discovered the Elephant Man in a London sideshow and admitted him to a small room in the Royal London Hospital, where he worked. To help with his upkeep, Treves decided to raise public awareness, and donations began to flow in. Merrick became a famous person, receiving many visitors, including the renowned actress Madge Kendall.

Initially, it was thought that he had cognitive disabilities because his shyness prevented him from expressing himself. In reality, he was intelligent and well-read, with a love for sentimental novels. Moreover, his artistic vein is well represented by the Mainz Cathedral Models and his letters. He was found dead in his bed in April 1890; his enormous head had broken his cervical vertebrae.

The story of this figure is one of the most powerful representations of the inner and social conflict between a body that defied common aesthetic norms and a mind eager to demonstrate full belonging to the human race. For this reason, he has been the subject of many works across different genres: from the progressive metal song by Mastodon, the famous Broadway screenplay created by Bernard Pomerance, to a cinematic masterpiece by David Lynch.

Study of the domain

Chosen items

The life story of Joseph Merrick has been the subject of numerous works, including films, books, songs, and scientific studies. The objective of this project is to explore the different types of objects related to Merrick, such as personal belongings, creative works inspired by him, and scholarly articles.

Image

"The Elephant Man"screenplay

This acclaimed screenplay, written by Bernard Pomerance, stages the tragic and inspiring life of Joseph Merrick, "The Elephant Man." The drama is based on the memoirs of Sir Frederick Treves, Merrick's doctor and close friend, as recounted in "The Elephant Man and Other Reminiscences." The play explores themes of humanity, dignity, and societal perception, offering an emotional look at Merrick's struggle against severe physical deformities and his quest for normalcy and respect. See more
Image

"The Elephant Man"movie

"The Elephant Man" is a 1980 biographical drama film depicting the life of Joseph Merrick, referred to as "John" in the film, a severely deformed man living in late 19th-century London. Directed by David Lynch, the film was both a critical and commercial success, featuring standout performances by John Hurt (Joseph Merrick) and Anthony Hopkins (the Physician Fredrick Treves). See more
Image

"Joseph Merrick"song

Joseph Merrick" is a instrumental track by the American heavy metal band Mastodon, featured on their critically acclaimed album "Leviathan." The song pays homage to the life and struggles of Joseph Merrick. The haunting melody captures the tragic yet inspiring essence of Merrick's story. See more
Image

Letter written by Joseph MerrickLetter

This letter, penned by Joseph Merrick during his residence at the London Hospital, Whitechapel, is addressed to his friend Miss Leila Maturin. In the letter, Merrick expresses his heartfelt gratitude for a book she had given him, offering a rare glimpse into his personal correspondence and the relationships he cherished. See more
Image

Joseph Merrick's hatHat

This green velvet flat cap with an attached fabric mask, featuring a stitched open slit for the eyes, was worn by Joseph Merrick, known as "The Elephant Man," during the 1880s. Merrick donned this cap and hood to maintain public discretion. As noted by Dr. Frederick Treves, his physician, "Merrick wore a disguise consisting of an oversized black cloak and a brown cap with a hessian sack covering his face." See more
Image

Model of Mainz CathedralModel

The model of Mainz Cathedral, constructed by Joseph Merrick, stands as a testament to his artistic talent. This piece was assembled from a pre-fabricated kit gifted to Merrick by the actress Madge Kendal, a benefactor who supported him during his time at the London Hospital. The model showcases Merrick's dexterity and creative spirit despite his physical limitations. See more
Image

"The Elephant Man and Other Reminiscences"Book

“The Elephant Man and Other Reminiscences" is a memoir by Sir Frederick Treves, the renowned surgeon who cared for Joseph Merrick. The book provides a compassionate account of Merrick's life and condition, as well as Treves' other notable medical experiences and observations during his career. It offers a rare glimpse into the challenges and triumphs of Victorian medicine and the humanity of one of its most famous patients. See more
Image

"Joseph Merrick Carte Da Visite"Picture

Carte de visite portrait photograph of Joseph Merrick: This photograph, circulated to members of the public circa 1889, was produced in the popular Carte de visite format, a small photograph patented in Paris by photographer André Adolphe Eugène Disdéri. It is now housed at the Royal London Hospital Museum. See more
Image

The Royal London HospitalPlace

The Royal London Hospital, established in 1740 and located in Whitechapel, London, is one of the oldest teaching hospitals in the United Kingdom. It is historically significant for providing care to Joseph Merrick who resided there from 1886 until his death in 1890 under the care of Dr. Frederick Treves. See more
Image

"The Proteus syndrome: the Elephant Man diagnosed"Scientific Article

Published in 1986, this medical article offers a retrospective diagnosis of the condition that afflicted Joseph Merrick. Written by researchers J A Tibbles and M M Cohen, the study critically re-evaluates earlier theories about Merrick's condition, ultimately dismissing them in favor of identifying it as Proteus syndrome. This rare genetic disorder is characterized by uncontrolled and asymmetrical growth of body tissues, a fitting namesake drawn from the shape-shifting Greek god Proteus. See more

Knowledge Organization

Conceptual Map

The initial phase of modeling involves illustrating the main concept using a conceptual map. This map must depict in natural language the real data obtained from the chosen items and represent the explicit relationship between them. Within the map, the elements in yellow represent the main concept and the 10 selected items while the elements in gray represent the metadata related to these items. Among these, the metadata shared between multiple items are highlighted with a yellow border. Adhering to the metadata standards of these institutions, we introduced additional relationships due to frequent categorization of data under overly general headings such as 'description'.

E / R Model

The Conceptual Map is now translated into a higher level of abstraction. With this Entity-Relationship model we provide a graphical representation of the entities that characterize the scenario such as people, places, dates and subjects and the relationship among them, offering a clearer and more structured overview of the scenario.

Metadata

Metadata Analysis

We conducted an analysis of the metadata provided by cultural institutions for the selected items. Some institutions explicitly stated the metadata standards they used, while others do not specified standards. For those, we applied a suitable generic metadata standard.

Item Name Object Type Provider Metadata Standard used by the provider Metadata Standard
The elephant man: a drama Screenplay Worldcat MARC 21 MARC 21
Joseph Merrick Song MusicBrainz XML(MMD) XML(MMD)
Letter from Joseph Merrick to Miss Leila Maturin Letter The Record Office for Leicestershire, Leicester and Rutland / DC Terms
The Proteus syndrome: the Elephant Man diagnosed Scientific Article National Library of Medicine MEDLINE/PubMed MEDLINE/PubMed
Model of Mainz cathedral Model Barts Health Archives ISAD(G) ISAD(G)
Green velvet flat cap Hat Barts Health Archives ISAD(G) ISAD(G)
Carte da Visite Portrait photograph of Joseph Merrick Photograph Barts Health Archives ISAD(G) ISAD(G)
The Elephant Man and other reminiscences Book Internet Archive MARC21 MARC21
The Royal London Hospital Place Library of Congress (LCNAF) MADS/RDF MADS/RDF
The Elephant Man Movie AFI (American Film Insititute) CWS CWS

Metadata

Metadata Alignment

Another important step in our project was mapping and comparing metadata properties to address information related to people (who), places (where), dates (when), and subjects/concepts (what). Where metadata alignment could not be found, we noted N/A in our documentation.

Property DCTerms MARC 21 XML(MMD) ISAD(G) CWS MADS/RDF MEDLINE/PubMed
has actor contributor N/A N/A Scope and content (CONTENT AND STRUCTURE AREA) Cast N/A N/A
has production company publisher N/A Label Administrative/Biographical history (CONTEXT AREA) Scope and content (CONTENT AND STRUCTURE AREA) Credits CorporateName N/A
has author creator 100 $a Artist, Name Name of creator(s) (CONTEXT AREA) Credits Personal Name Type Author (AU)
has producer publisher N/A Label Administrative/Biographical history (CONTEXT AREA) Scope and content (CONTENT AND STRUCTURE AREA) Credits N/A N/A
has recipient N/A N/A N/A Administrative/Biographical history (CONTEXT AREA) Scope and content (CONTENT AND STRUCTURE AREA) N/A N/A N/A
has publisher publisher 260 $b Label Administrative/Biographical history (CONTEXT AREA) Credtis CorporateName N/A
belonged to provenance N/A N/A Administrative/Biographical history (CONTEXT AREA) Immediate source of acquisition or transfer (CONTEXT AREA) Scope and content (CONTENT AND STRUCTURE AREA) N/A N/A N/A
Property DCTerms MARC 21 XML(MMD) ISAD(G) CWS MADS/RDF MEDLINE/PubMed
has place of publication Coverage.spatial 264 $a Area, City Immediate source of acquisition or transfer (CONTEXT AREA) Scope and content (CONTENT AND STRUCTURE AREA) Country of Reference City Type, Country Place of Publication (PL)
held at coverage.spatial 852 $a Place, Educational Institution Existence and location of originals (ALLIED MATERIALS AREA) N/A Associated Locale N/A
has location Coverage.spatial N/A Area, City Existence and location of originals (ALLIED MATERIALS AREA) N/A City Type, Country N/A
was created at Coverage.spatial 260 $e Place Administrative/Biographical history (CONTEXT AREA) Scope and content (CONTENT AND STRUCTURE AREA) Country of Reference Associated Locale N/A
published in isPartOf 773 N/A Administrative/Biographical history (CONTEXT AREA) Scope and content (CONTENT AND STRUCTURE AREA) Credits N/A Journal Title (JT)
Property DC Terms MARC 21 XML(MMD) ISAD(G) CWS MADS/RDF MEDLINE/PubMed
has publication date Date issued 264 $c Release, Date Date(s) (IDENTITY STATEMENT AREA) Year of Reference Temporal Type Date of Publication (DP)
has date of creation Date created 264 $g N/A Date(s) (IDENTITY STATEMENT AREA) Year of Reference Temporal Type Date Created (DA)
donated in date 561 N/A Date(s) (IDENTITY STATEMENT AREA) Year of Reference Temporal Type Immediate source of acquisition or transfer
Property DCTerms MARC 21 XML(MMD) ISAD(G) CWS MADS/RDF MEDLINE/PubMed
has genre type 655 $a Genre Scope and content (CONTENT AND STRUCTURE AREA) Genre Genre/Form Type Publication Type (PT)
has type type 655 $a Type property Scope and content (CONTENT AND STRUCTURE AREA) N/A Simple Type Publication Type (PT)
has language language 041 $a Work, languages Language/scripts of materia (CONDITIONS OF ACCESS AND USE AREA) Original Language Language Type Language (LA)
has subject subject 650 N/A Scope and content (CONTENT AND STRUCTURE AREA) N/A Topic Type N/A
has title title 245 $a Release, title Title (IDENTITY STATEMENT AREA) Title Title Type Title (TI)
based on source N/A N/A Scope and content (CONTENT AND STRUCTURE AREA) Relationship Source N/A
has release title isPartOf 773 Release, title Title (IDENTITY STATEMENT AREA) Series / Serial Title Type N/A
has material medium N/A N/A Physical characteristics and technical requirements (CONDITIONS OF ACCESS AND USE AREA) N/A Medium Type N/A
has name title N/A Name property Title (IDENTITY STATEMENT AREA) Title Name Type N/A
has identifier identifier 020 (ISBN) / 024 (Other) Id Reference code(s) (IDENTITY STATEMENT AREA ) Identifier Identifyer Source

Knowledge Organization

Theoretical Model

In this step, the team refined the original Conceptual Map by integrating new data from various sources and establishing additional connections to the existing entities. This process was carried out in natural language. Additionally, we categorized the data into four groups: WHO (marked in pink), WHERE (marked in green), WHEN (marked in purple), and WHAT (marked in blue). New relationships and properties were represented with yellow arrows.

Enhanced E/R Model

At this stage, transitioning to an Entity/Relationships model once more, we refined the original E/R model and created a new graph based on the theoretical model to reach a deeper insights into entity relationships and attributes.

Conceptual Model

Having taken these steps, we transitioned from the theoretical model to the formal representation, known as the ontological approach. This involves creating a conceptual model by incorporating existing schemas, vocabularies, and ontologies ensuring conformity with established conventions and terminologies.

These are the ontologies that we chose:

  • @prefix foaf: http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/
  • @prefix dcterms: http://purl.org/dc/terms/
  • @prefix schema: https://schema.org
  • @prefix mo: http://purl.org/ontology/mo/
  • @prefix dbo: http://dbpedia.org/ontology/
  • @prefix vir: http://w3id.org/vir
  • @prefix frbr: http://purl.org/vocab/frbr/core
  • @prefix fabio: http://purl.org/spar/fabio
  • @prefix crm: http://www.cidoc-crm.org/cidoc-crm/
  • @prefix gndo: http://d-nb.info/standards/elementset/gnd
  • @prefix gvp: http://vocab.getty.edu/ontology
  • @prefix frapo: http://purl.org/cerif/frapo
  • @prefix cwrc: https://sparql.cwrc.ca/ontologies/cwrc.html#

Knowledge Representation

Items description

In this section, we revisited the items to describe them using the properties defined in the Conceptual Model. For each item, we created a table with three columns corresponding to the elements of a triple: subject, predicate, and object. Each row represents a single statement.

Subject Predicate Object
Screenplay rdf:type screenplay
Screenplay dcterms:publisher Samuel French
Screenplay dcterms:creator Bernard Pomerance
Screenplay schema:datePublished 1979
Screenplay schema:genre Biographical Drama
Screenplay dcterms:title The Elephant Man
Screenplay schema:identifier ISBN:9780573608742
Screenplay schema:character Frederick Treves
Screenplay dcterms:language English
Screenplay dcterms:subject Joseph Merrick
Screenplay schema:contentLocation London
Screenplay schema:character Madge Kendal
Screenplay schema:temporalCoverage Victorian Era
Screenplay dbpedia-owl:basedOn The Elephant Man and other reminiscences
Subject Predicate Object
Movie rdf:type Movie
Movie schema:actor John Hurt
Movie schema:actor Anne Bancroft
Movie schema:actor Anthony Hopkins
Movie dcterms:creator David Lynch
Movie dcterms:publisher Brooks Film
Movie schema:countryOfOrigin United States of America
Movie schema:datePublished 1988/10/03
Movie schema:genre Drama
Movie schema:genre Biographical
Movie crm:P62 depicts Model
Movie schema:contentLocation London
Movie dcterms:subject Joseph Merrick
Movie dcterms:language English
Movie dcterms:title The Elephant man
Movie schema:temporalCoverage Victorian Era
Subject Predicate Object
Song dcterms:subject Joseph Merrick
Song dcterms:language English
Song dcterms:creator Mastodon
Song dcterms:title Leviathan
Song rdf:type Song
Song dcterms:title Joseph Merrick
Song schema:datePublished 2004
Song mo:producer Matt Bayles
Song schema:genre Progressive Metal
Subject Predicate Object
Letter rdf:type Letter
Letter schema:recipient Miss Leila Maturin
Letter dcterms:rightsHolder The Record Office
Letter schema:dateCreated 1889/10
Letter dcterms:title Letter from Joseph [Carey] Merrick, London Hospital, Whitechapel to Miss L[eila] Maturin, Sunderland House, Islay, N[orth] B[ritain]
Letter dcterms:creator Joseph Merrick
Letter dcterms:language English
Letter schema:locationCreated The Royal London Hospital
Subject Predicate Object
Artifact rdf:type Hat
Artifact dcterms:title Green velvet flat cap
Artifact schema:material Grey fabric veil, small, triangular shaped, a nylon thread
Artifact schema:dateCreated 1880
Artifact dcterms:rightsHolder Royal London Hospital Museum
Artifact dcterms:provenance Joseph Merrick
Subject Property Object
Model rdf:type Model
Model dcterms:creator Joseph Merrick
Model schema:dateCreated 1886
Model schema:material pre-printed card
Model fabio:has date received 1917
Model dcterms:title German model of Mainz cathedral
Model schema:locationCreated The Royal London Hospital
Model dcterms:rightsHolder Royal London Hospital Museum
Model frapo:is donated by Madge Kendal
Subject Predicate Object
Book dcterms:subject Joseph Merrick
Book dcterms:language English
Book schema:character Miss Leila Maturin
Book rdf:type Book
Book dcterms:title The Elephant Man and other reminiscences
Book dcterms:publisher Cassell&Co
Book schema:datePublished 1923/02
Book crm:P62 depicts Joseph Merrick's Hat
Book schema:character Tom Norman
Book rdcterms:creator Frederick Treves
Book fabio:has place of publication London
Subject Predicate Object
Portrait schema:dateCreated 1889
Portrait dcterms:title Carte de visite portrait photograph of Joseph Merrick
Portrait dcterms:creator Unknown
Portrait dcterms:rightsHolder Royal London Hospital Museum
Portrait dcterms:subject Joseph Merrick
Portrait rdf:type Visual Item
Subject Predicate Object
Hospital dcterms:isPartOf National Health Service
Hospital rdf:type Hospital
Hospital schema:dateCreated 1740
Hospital schema:containedInPlace London
Subject Predicate Object
Journal Article rdf:type Journal Article
Journal Article dcterms:subject Proteus syndrome
Journal Article dcterms:subject Joseph Merrick
Journal Article schema:identifier bmj.293.6548.683
Journal Article schema:datePublished 01
Journal Article dcterms:title The Proteus syndrome: the Elephant Man diagnosed
Journal Article schema:genre Biography
Journal Article dcterms:creator M M Cohen
Journal Article dcterms:creator J A Tibbles
Journal Article dcterms:isPartOf British medical journal
Journal Article fabio:hasPlaceOfPublication England
Journal Article dcterms:language English

RDF Production

URI creation

For the creation of internal URIs, we used the namespace "https://w3id.org/the-elephant-man/". To describe the entities, we divided them into the following classes:

  • person/
  • item/
  • place/
  • time/
  • concept/
  • language/
  • organization/
  • occupation/
and concept into two further subclasses genre/ and disease/ to more clearly describe the entities in our domain.

As an example, here is an item (Letter) and the internal URIs connected to it.

Label Link
Item https://w3id.org/the-elephant-man/item/Letter
Joseph Merrick https://w3id.org/the-elephant-man/person/Joseph-Merrick
English https://w3id.org/the-elephant-man/language/English
The Record Office https://w3id.org/the-elephant-man/organization/The-Record-Office
The Royal London Hospital https://w3id.org/the-elephant-man/place/The-Royal-London-Hospital
Miss Leila Maturin https://w3id.org/the-elephant-man/person/Miss-Leila-Maturin

CSV to RDF with Python

Using a Python script, we extracted the content of the .csv files to obtain the subject - predicate - object triples and added them to an internal graph. At the end of the script, the graph is serialized into a Turtle file.

If you want to see the turtle serialization click here.

RDF Visualization

After obtaining the Turtle file, we placed its contents into RDF Grapher to obtain the visualization of the RDF graph.

Text Conversions

In this phase, our team utilized various tools to thoroughly analyze the digital book edition of “The Elephant Man and Other Reminiscences” by Frederick Treves. We employed XML/TEI encoding, XSLT conversion, RDF/XML representation, and Python scripting.

XML/TEI

TEI (Text Encoding Initiative) is a standard for encoding texts, primarily in the humanities, to ensure their preservation, interoperability, and accessibility in digital formats. We have encoded an XML/TEI document to represent the textual structure of selected parts of the first chapter from “The Elephant Man and Other Reminiscences.” This document captures fundamental sections, such as the first encounter between Merrick and Treves and the description of Merrick's body. The original text has been transcribed faithfully without additions or modifications, except for the selection of specific paragraphs. The XML/TEI document of “The Elephant Man and Other Reminiscences” text's sample is available at this link.

XSLT for XML to HTML conversion

This section demonstrates the application of XSLT (Extensible Stylesheet Language Transformations) to convert XML documents into HTML format. The primary objective is to present XML data on web platforms in a visually appealing and user-friendly manner while maintaining the document integrity. The XSLT document can be accessed via this link.

Python scripts for TEI conversion can be found here.

You can view the resulting HTML document from the conversion here.

XML/TEI to RDf conversion

Using Python's XML library, we extracted information from the nodes of the XML/TEI file and transformed it into RDF triples. Then, we serialized the graph in Turtle format, containing all the triples.

Here the link to the python file.

Finally, we uploaded the Turtle file to RDF Grapher to visualize the graph.